Skip to main content

Can White People Play The Blues?

Cuttin to the chase, here is an argument from Phil Jenkins in the recent volume Blues and Philosophy from Wiley-Blackwell:  Co-edited by yours truly:)

CONTEMPORARY PERSPECTIVE: 
DeJeana Burke & The Oakland Blues Divas: 




Phil Jenkins. Yes,he's white


Conclusion: White people cannot BCE!

1.The term ‘blues’ is ambiguous in meaning as it may refer to a distinct ‘blues musical form’ (BMF) or to ‘blues cultural expression’ (BCE)

2. BMF is in principle accessible to all, and can actually be performed by anyone with sufficient training and motor skills.

3.  White people can acquire the requisite training and motor skills.

4. Thus, white people CAN play BME.
Muddy Waters

5. However, Blues as Cultural Expression (BCE) is only accessible to people that are members of the social group that created blues.  Specifically, to people that share the history of oppression and injustice of Blacks in America going back to slavery times. 

6.Defending  (3) above, requires a clear account of what it means to be a member of a social group.  Jenkins claims that some form of ‘learning and imitating’ the expressions of  other group members’  lived experiences,  internalizing these, and using them to express one’s own experiences of that general type, are necessary conditions for one’s expressive behavior to count as a specific form of cultural expression. You got to inherit the blues!

7.  Thus, blues as cultural expression is only available to those that have the expressive options of Black 
    Americans suffering the indignities of oppression.
Son House

8. No white person can have those expressive options. (it may also be true that some black people cannot 
    either, but that is fine for this argument.)

9. Thus, no white person can perform BCE.

10. Thus, that’s the fact jack!!

QUESTION: Do you agree?  Can white people BCE?  If so, where exactly does the above argument to the contrary go wrong?  


A little relevant music below.  
I'll leave it to you to decide whether these clips confirm or refute Jenkins' argument.  So, here is a little blues evidence!

an old blues playlist I made once upon a time.
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL54E770A8819377A3

Memphis Slim: Born With The Blues
*don't learn it in school....just have to inherit the blues people!

Lightnin' Hopkins: Death Blues
*To quote: "everybody dies, every livin' people dies...when that tick tock stops ticking....you ain't keepin' time no more."

The Land Where The Blues Began (so good!): Mix-Tape From Alan Lomax


Howlin' Wolf: What is the blues?
*sounds like a lotta people I know, especially with our recent economic woes.

Parting Shot From Lightnin', my FAVORITE.
 The Woman Named Mary

*we all suffer sure enough, but are we doing the same thing when we're all suffering?

Comments

  1. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I don't believe that white people can truly play the Blues. To play Blues type music, yes. The blues essentially "evolved" during the slave trades as a means to communicate and make the labor they were forced to do go by in a more upbeat atmosphere. Even after the emancipation proclamation, music remained a main vehicle to vent frustrations. The songs they sang were like mini diaries of their daily lives (railroad, work, saloons, women, prison...) short chronicles of what they have lived through and what they are/were still living through. White music could have been said it was similar in tone and harmony and was sang happily of life events while black music or the "Blues" was almost vicious and depressing and the vision of the way blacks lived. They sang about prison and slave work the love/lust of their many relationships with no real feeling involved or invested. Death was not so much sad but a fact of life. I feel the quality of Blues music then was so strong and deep. It was a state of mind and not just a song someone came up with because the beat sounded right. A lot of the Blues songs don't really have any specific beat per se, just wherever the singers hands seem to trail along the guitar at that moment. It didn't take months in any recording studio to be perfected because it came directly from he heart and soul of the singer. The music was about life and the misery they lived. They drank to numb the pain, they had sex to feel the companionship of another person but couldn't unnecessary give that person their whole heart and soul because most of these people were broken. From the lives they have lived and the repression they were dealing with. Now..... how can a lil ol white person come along and say that they can sing the BLUES!!!!! The stresses Americans deal with in this day in age can never compare to what the black people had to go through then. No comparison..... Technically, I believe the true blues can really only be sung by the people who have experienced living in this time period. The blues sung now is more what you could call modern day blues. I just dont personally see how any white person could justifiably legitimately play true Blues music.
    artical: Race, Ethnicity, Expressive Authenticity-Can White People Sing the Blues?

    ReplyDelete
  3. I agree that "that's how it is!" Similar to Carley, I believe that the ability to fully understand the blues as cultural expression stems from experiencing structural and historical racism and watching your kin and your community suffer injustice and oppression. I further believe that the blues are a form of resilience that only those who have experienced true adversity are able to develop. Like Memphis Blue explains, "[you] don't learn it in school....just have to inherit the blues."

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Trolley Car Blues: Of Mules and Men

Trolley Car Blues: Of mules and men At first it seems a bit of stretch to put far fetched thought experiments with real world gritty blues, but that worry fades.  Trolleys and trains loom large as themes in blues music, and of course in the actual production of the tracks and cars.  Take  Michael Sandel's presentation of a couple well know versions of the "trolley problem"  as presented in his well know class on Justice at Harvard. One hub issue in the Trolley cases is how to compare the worth and value of a human life to other human lives, and how to determine costs and benefits, rights and obligations with that variable in mind when we make decisions which affect multiple lives in divergent ways.  Sandel notes that we have a difficulty of finding a 'common currency' with which to represent the relative worth of multiple and diverse human lives.  The traditional philosophical problem is called 'the problem of  intersubjective utility compa...
Ethics And Blues:  An exercise in moral psychology Ethics and Blues is a chronicle of living ,  mattering  and learning   told   through  The Blues    in Oakland, ca. The fruits of this inquiry will provide a moral psychology for grounded moral inquiry. Answers are published quarterly featuring blues musicians commemorated on the Oakland Walk of Fame. Contributions are received in all forms of media and expression. We ask only two questions, but they get a lot done:  1. Why does The Blues matter to your life? 2. Why does Oakland matter to your life?  3.Why does your life matter to you? A Blues Life:   Ronnie Stewart A Blues Life: "Terrible" Tom Bowden Tom talks blues with students from University of San Francisco. More Rea l  blues lives  and  why they matter  coming soon!  Produced in conjunction with  West Coast Blues Societ...